Monday, August 23, 2010

Top 10 Technology Advances of All Time


Kate, over at f(t) inspired (pun intended) me to write a little about technology after reviewing a TI seminar she attended.

So without further ado...
The 10 Most Important Technological Advances in Math Education (chronologically):
1.     Writing utensil (to write on cave walls)
2.     Paper (because cave walls are hard to take with you)
3.     Ruler (and, in general, the concept of measuring devices)
4.     Abacus (yeah for being able to do large arithmetic problems quickly)
5.     Printing press (makin’ a copy)
6.     Slide Rule (yeah for being able to do large arithmetic problems quicklier)
7.     The industrial revolution (education for the masses…errr…where we learn to sit still and follow directions)
8.     Sputnik (not directly used in math ed, but this played a huge role in shaping our current curriculum)
9.     Computers (beginning with its mad arithmetic skills, case checking skills and evolving into its use for modeling)
10. The internet (for resources, networking, social media learning, etc)
And as a bonus…
11. The TI n’spire

Initially, I put #11 on here in jest but I’m beginning to consider the actual importance of this technology (and not in a good way).  Specifically, I believe that the n’spire and it’s predecessors have played a significant role in shaping standardized testing and that this standardized testing has shaped recent curriculum as much, if not more, than sputnik or the industrial revolution.

Without much thinking, my first criticism of this list is that it is pretty 20th century-centric.  Anyway, something to ponder.  Anything you would add? 

Thursday, August 12, 2010

My Blog Post about Math For Love's Blog Post about Math Mamma's Blog Post about...

Math for Love just wrote a post that I really enjoyed about play.  Go there and check it out and then come back here for the post-game analysis.  I was originally just going to comment over there, but this got too long.  Anyway, I found that it was a really well articulated process of how I want students to work with math problems.  Since you're good at following directions you've already read this but let's recap.
  1. Play (Expansion)
  2. Ask questions (Reflection)
  3. Choose a question that you really want to explore (Contraction)
  4. Try to answer the question with what you already know
  5. If that fails (i.e., if your question is deep enough), start exploring other ways to approach the question, with your own ideas and by looking at what others have done. A teacher or expert can be very useful here (“Oh, you want to figure out how far apart those two dots are? Have you ever heard of the Pythagorean Theorem? It works like this…”)
  6. Refine your question
  7. Repeat Steps 4-6 until you solve your question
  8. Explain your work to people
  9. Realize that you can’t really explain it, and refine your solution until you can actually write down an explanation.
  10. If in a class or group, share your work with the group, or have the group come to an agreement on how things really are.
  11. Satisfaction.

I would stop at #11 (and although this is hard, I would also aim to have students feel #11 after every step).

12. Tweak the original "rules" in some way and return to #1.

In terms of addressing the floundering that can occur in progressive models, I think the key (not that this is easy) is teaching kids how to do #1 through #11 (well, imho the cycle of  #1 through #12).  Even "playing" can be taught. Consider the development kids go through when playing boardgames.  They start with games like Chutes & Ladders which has absolutely no strategy and children simply enjoy the unknown of what you're going to roll next and where you'll end up.  This eventually evolves into greater sophisticated game play where students have to make decisions (whether or not to buy that property in Monopoly, for example).  This evolves into more sophisticated strategies such as thinking ahead (Chess), thinking about your opponent's thinking (Settlers of Catan), making inferences based on past play (Poker), etc.

I believe the game metaphor can be extended to math problems, even traditional ones.  Just as an example, consider how the "rules" of subtraction evolve throughout elementary school:
1. Single digit whole #'s with the first being larger than the second
2. Multiple digit whole #'s with the first being larger than the second
3. Multiple digit whole #'s with the first being larger than the second, but requiring borrowing
4. Whole #'s with the second being larger than the first
5. Fractions
6. Subtraction of integers
7. Subtraction of rationals
etc.

We change (usually relaxing) the rules as we progress through the curriculum.  It's nice that this also mirrors what mathematicians often do, relaxing or restricting conditions and exploring the ramifications.

Videotaping my classroom

It's been a while as I've been camping/out of town/packing/moving/unpacking.  That's all (well, mostly) finished now, so I'm going to try and squeeze in some more detailed responses about the challenges of minimally defined problems before school starts up again. Before I do that, though, I need some help. Hopefully there's still one or two people out there reading this. 

So because I will be conducting research and just for my own good, I'm planning on doing some serious videotaping of my classroom this year (not too much, though, as too much data can be just as useless as too little data).  Here's what I would ideally want. 

1. A camera permanently installed above every table (4 desks per table) where, with a quick click at the computer I can turn on one or all of these cameras and record video/audio.  It doesn't need to be HD or 3D, but it definitely needs to be audible and it would be really helpful if it were readable (meaning you can read what the students are writing). 

Of course I should have known that this wouldn't be as easy as just buying 4 webcams, a USB hub, some long cables, and some sort of brace to hold these in place.  I haven't actually tried this, but it seems from some reading on the interweb that this doesn't work because the software has trouble/is unable to detect multiple cameras at once.  Grrr...any advice?  Any advice that doesn't include me also buying 4 computers?  

So...I yield to the tech-guru-blog writers/readers out there for suggestions.  The prize?  I'll write up a detailed description of what I end up getting to work and, barring issues with release forms, some videos of students doing math.  Dan Meyer has no problem creating clones of himself, so this should be a piece of cake.

...which brings me to my second request.

2. Anyone have some suggestions on the easiest way to make student vidoes anonymous so that I can share work without compromising student privacy?  What I really want is for someone to write a program that will take a live action video as its input and output a cartoon version. I'd even pay for the premium version that creates corresponding cartoon voices too.  Sean Cornally created his own grading tool for standards based grading.  Can this be his next project?  Please?  Worst case, I can always blur out faces in Adobe Creative Suite, but ideally I'd like something more automated.  I guess the other option is somehow getting parents' permission to post videos of their sixth grade child on the open web.  In the end, the cartoon idea might be my best bet. 

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Minimally Defined Problems, Chapter 2

There is understandable skepticism out there (and some not so far away in the comments of previous posts) about students' ability to engage and come up with rich mathematical problems starting with what I am calling minimally defined problems. First, an anecdote of success with this approach that happened yesterday with some real, live 2nd, 3rd, and 4th graders at Math for Love.

These kids were given a chessboard and asked to come up with some math questions. Link on over if you want to see the great things the kids came up with.

Now don't get me wrong, I'm sure I could find an anecdote showing how a bear dancing on the back of a goat can lead to better proficiency with multiplication tables. One anecdote does not make a theory and should not send everyone running to rewrite the curriculum.

On the other hand, this doesn't mean that this anecdote should be ignored...

Anyway, I first want to address some of the issues/concerns about minimally defined problems and student posed problems that were brought up in earlier posts (comments that actually hit on many of the concerns that I am addressing in my proposal). Concerns/questions addressed here can be loosely separated into the following five questions:

1. Can this approach (or any approach for that matter) increase intrinsic motivation?
Ms. V: “I was a good math student, and I like puzzles, but I have very low "task-commitment"...Certain types of problems in certain contexts will totally get me working doggedly long past when anyone else cares. But other types of puzzles bore me (once I realize there's a trick/strategy/etc)....when I hit a wall and have run through everything I can think of...[So] how do you build stamina for such things in your students? Or is it just a mismatch between problem and personality? Or are these actually not such great problems, and the really great ones DO promote commitment? Or am I just lazy?”

2. How do you change the dominant culture of explanation-example-exercise-answer-satisfaction and should this culture be changed?
O: “I think I would be initially frustrated because the question is so open ended and there doesn't appear to be a right answer." 
Perdita: “If I'd had the gumption I have now I'd have written "What comes after 5? Answer: 6". Not sure what I'd have done then, but you'd have lost me for ever.”
Perdita: " you were apparently targeting it at middle schoolers, but my 6yo answered it instantly, and I'd certainly expect any 11yo with reasonable number sense to do so, if not distracted by wondering what teacher wanted today...”

3. Are students (specifically, sixth grade students) capable of engaging in this kind of work?
Max: “It's very hard for me to see how a student without any background or context could approach that assignment in a productive way.”
Perdita: "the space of mathematical problems that are solvable with effort by a given person is very, very narrow by comparison with the space of all problems that that person can formulate. Preduction: if you ask children to make up their own problems, almost all of them will be either trivial, or insoluble."

4. What does this look like on a day to day basis?
Ms V: “What you do when they arrive in class could drastically change the results on future similar assignments, though. What *would* you do?”
O: "I think it can be frustrating to do work which you are uncertain if it is in the right direction because you can feel the work is pointless.”

5. What should we value in a mathematics education?
Perdita: "[This site] seems to be an exemplar of a trend to favour trivial creativity over solving hard problems, and it seems likely to encourage teacher-pleasing rather than mathematical work. "

Answers Responses forthcoming...

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Paper Puzzle

I've been off the grid for about ten days, but still have things to share from my math teacher circle workshop from before I left.  Here's a puzzle for you.  Make the following with one piece of normal paper and a pair of scissors.  Nothing else.  No tape, glue, or photoshop magic.

Thursday, June 24, 2010

A coin flipping game...

I'm attending a math teacher circle workshop this week.  Yesterday afternoon we had a great speaker who talked about an old favorite of mine.

You and a friend play a game where each of you pick a sequence of three heads or tails.  Let's say your friend chooses THH and you choose HHH.  You then repeatedly flip a coin until one of the sequences shows up.  So if you flipped THTHH, your friend would win.  Is this a fair game?

Oh, if you have a solution feel free to write a comment, but give people a spoiler alert.

Tuesday, June 22, 2010

Math Circles Workshop

Today was the first day of a week long workshop put on by a local chapter of math teacher circles.  What a fun day!  We spent the morning working on problems and talking about problem solving.  An amazing group of high school students from Los Angeles presented a workshop this afternoon about their work in The Algebra Project and the Young People Project.

This was a big take away for me from the morning session.  Any guesses on what it is?