Monday, March 14, 2011

Cow Pi Day

Happy Pi Day!  Woo hoo!  March 14!  3.14 (btw, MIT releases admission decisions today at 1:59, the next three digits of pi).

Ok, enough happiness and joy and thoughtless love of mathematical constants that sound like yummy desserts.  I'm going to risk putting a big cow pie in your Pi Day and talk about the absurdities of the whole idea.

Base number systems


Pi (the ratio of the circumference to the diameter of ANY circle) is approximately 3.14159265358.  Well, that's what it is in base-10.  By base-10, I mean using a number system with 10 symbols (0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9).  In this system we use these ten symbols to count up and then when we run out we use a combination of these symbols and the power of place value to describe larger values (372 is really shorthand for 3 hundreds, 7 tens, and 2 ones).  Humans haven't always used based-10 though and there isn't anything particularly special about it.  The Mayans used a base-20 system and the Babylonians used a base-60 system.  Yes, that means you'd have to learn 60 different symbols, but the number 3599 is only 2 digits.  Some believe that when computers take over the world we'll be forced to use a base-2 number system.  Computers like this system because they can really only understand two things: "electricity is flowing" and "electricity is not flowing."  You might have seen binary numbers before (0, 1, 10, 11, 100, etc).

Some mathematical concepts remain regardless of what base you're in.  A prime number in base 10 will be a prime number in base 2, base 20, base 60, and base 243112609-1 (which is currently the largest known prime number).  Pi, on the other hand, will not always be 3.14159265358.....


Pi in base-2?


First of all, what in the world does that even mean.  Remember how someone (that would be me) mentioned earlier that 372 is really shorthand for 3 hundreds, 7 tens, and 2 ones.  We can also think about this as [;3\times10^2+7\times10^1+2\times10^0;].  Remember that [;10^0;]=1 (which can be explained using, among other methods, pattern sniffing with decreasing powers).  Well this isn't a coincidence and if we wanted to describe the number of days in a non-leap-year year in base-5, we'd write it as 2430 or [;2\times5^3+4\times5^2+3\times5^1+0\times5^0;].  Well, we might use symbols other than 2, 4, 3, and 0 but you hopefully get the idea.  Anyway, this idea can be continued into the decimal realm.  The first few digits of pi in base-10 are 3.14159 which, in its expanded form, can be written as [;3\times10^0+1\times\frac{1}{10^1}+4\times\frac{1}{10^2}+1\times\frac{1}{10^3}+5\times\frac{1}{10^4}+9\times\frac{1}{10^5};] or [;3\times10^0+1\times10^{-1}+4\times10^{-2}+1\times10^{-3}+5\times10^{-4}+9\times10^{-5};]. This just means that there are 3 ones, 1 tenth, 4 hundredths, 1 thousandth, 5 ten thousandths, and 9 hundred thousandths.  So what would this look like in base 2?  Well we'd just need to figure out how many eights, fours, twos, ones, halves, fourths, eighths, sixteenths, etc there are in pi.  Well that sounds like a fun project to figure out.

Pi Day in other bases
One nice thing about figuring out pi in other bases is that I can give you the answers without really giving anything away (the method is the hard...err fun...part).  So...

Base 2: 11.00100100001111 (1 two, 1 one, no halves and fourths, 1 eighth, etc)
Base 3: 10.01021101222201
Base 4: 3.02100333122220
Base 5: 3.03232214303343
Base 6: 3.05033005141512
Base 7: 3.06636514320361
Base 8: 3.11037552421026
Base 9: 3.12418812407442  

Anyway, you can make the argument that base-10 is our normal base and that makes today special (although our calendar system really isn't a base 10 system.  It's more of a mixture of base-7, base-10, base-12, and base 28/29/30/31).  Sort of...

My point is not to rain on your Pi Day parade.  I'm all for having days where people actually want to talk about and think about math. I'm just saying that October 1st could also be Pi Day (in base 3).  Or March 2nd, 3rd, 5th, 6th, 11th, and 12th.

Maybe we should just call March Pi Month?

Monday, March 7, 2011

If It's Not Scottish Calculus, It's Crap

In memory ay me matile Colin Maclaurin, here's a summary ay whit ah did in mah Calculus BC class teh day bfer yeserday (ok, I'm afraid that's all the Scottish I know).

From our work with geometric series, we knew that [;\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} x^n =\frac{1}{1-x};] if |x| < 1


A complete side note...I'm using Text the World to embed all the mathy stuff (thanks Sue).  While I've found it to be a bit buggy and clunky, it supposedly will work in blogger, google docs, gmail, etc. so I'm excited about the possibility.  This is my first attempt to use this so let me know if you're having trouble reading anything.

Anyway, from an algebraic perspective, I think this is quite surprising.  Basically, we're saying that this infinite polynomial is equal to a nice "simple" rational expression.

So is this true for other functions?

I asked my students what functions would be especially interesting to look at.

[;x^2+2x-4;] is not a terribly interesting expression to write as a polynomial.  sin(x) on the other hand...that would be curious.

Here's what they came up with as a class:
  • trig functions
  • log functions
  • [;e^x;] 
  • [;\sqrt{x};] 
I then had the following dialogue:

Me: So [;e^x;] is a particularly interesting function in calculus because...

Class: it's derivative is also [;e^x;]

Me: Great.  Try and find a polynomial with this same property.

They broke into small groups and began exploring.  Every group quickly realized that a finite polynomial won't cut it.  They then began trying different infinite polynomials.  I gave a few groups some guidance around starting with [;a_0+a_1x+a_2x^2+a_3x^3+...;] and then trying to find the coefficients that would make the property of f(x)=f'(x) hold.  Different groups approached this in different ways.  Some differentiated [;a_0+a_1x+a_2x^2+a_3x^3+...;] to get [;a_1+2a_2x+3a_3x^2+...;] and then set the coefficients of each power to be equal to each other.  One group did something similar with the integral instead of the derivative.  Another group did something similar to this, but in more of an informal way where they realized that as you repeatedly differentiate you'll end up with factorials in from of your coefficients and then played around with some different polynomials with factorials in them.

I didn't help at all.   To my students' credit, when I asked 15 minutes later if they wanted us to come back together and talk/get hints/share ideas.  I got a resounding no.  Woo hoo!


They ended up working independently for about 30 minutes.  Every group found a polynomial that worked. Some groups realized that any multiple of their solution would have the property that f(x)=f'(x).  Two groups went further and attempted to define some equality between [;e^x;] and their polynomial.  One individual began working to find a polynomial with derivative characteristics to sin(x) ie f(x)=-f''(x).  Anyway, everyone independently came up with some version of
[;\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{a_0x^n}{n!};]

I was pretty excited about this.

Sure, we still have work to do in terms of formalization to define a more robust definition of equality (more than just having two functions with the same property).  It'll be interesting, though, to see if this helps students understand MacLaurin Series and Taylor Series.

Friday, February 18, 2011

Reason #792 I Love Mathematics

Is 80 degrees twice as warm as 40 degrees?  Discuss...




Ok, so obviously I wouldn't be posting this if there weren't some subtlety to this question.  I will say that three days ago I was pretty confident in my initial answer to this question.

Monday, February 14, 2011

Tracking Study

Probably most appropriate for twitter, but I'm still holding out on that end...

At the Escape from the Textbook conference I attended last Saturday, Jo Boaler referenced a large scale study in England on tracking.  A cursory search came up empty so I came here to let someone else do the work of finding it.  Ok, ok, not really.  Actually, I was hoping someone familiar with the study could point me in the right direction.

Thanks!

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Escape from the Textbook Conference

On Saturday I'm attending what I hope to be a great conference at The Urban School of San Francisco: Escape from the Textbook with speakers Jo Boaler (What's Math Got to Do With It), Paul Zeitz (The Art and Craft of Problem Solving), and me (too many books to name). Ok, I'm not really one of the speakers but I will be leading an afternoon workshop that I am calling Habits of Mind: From Student-Posed Problems to Assessment. 

Here's the plan:
We will complete a high speed version of a project where students create, explore, and generalize visual counting patterns (pile patterns for example). Sprinkled in will be discussions of how mathematical habits of mind (aka problem solving, aka mathematical practice) can be developed and assessed. Come prepared to do some math. 
Basically, we're going to start with


and go from there...

Here's the current draft of my powerpoint (zzzz) presentation.  I've never done this before (mostly because I've never been finished mostly finished putting together a presentation this far in advance). Obviously, there are lots of pieces that need to be filled in (I kind of hate powerpoints that don't have pieces that need to be filled in) but I'm hoping that I can get some feedback beforehand, send participants here during, and continue the conversation afterwards.

Here are some additional resources related to the workshop.




Supposedly there will be attempts to stream the conference for those of you that fail to scalp tickets between now and then.  We'll see how well this works, but stop by if you have some time (9-3PST).

Monday, February 7, 2011

Teaching via Games: The Introduction

I like games.  Board games, video games, sports, Bear/Ninja/Cowboy, you name it.  I've even managed to get to a place where I even enjoy games when I lose.  I know...mom and dad are so proud.  When I moved to California, one of my best craigslist furniture finds was a nice big coffee table that opens up to reveal a not-so-secret compartment.  Mine's filled with board games.  Below are some of the most recent games I've played and/or added to the bowels of the coffee table.  


There are lots of games that are explicitly and implicitly mathematical.  Some a great and some are terrible.


Math Mama Writes has introduced me to some of the great ones.  Math for Love has a great post cautioning us that any game labeled as a "fun math game" is like calling something you would ingest a food product--typically not a good sign.
If your goal is to teach and you just slap the word “fun” on at the end, you end up with garbage. On the other hand, if you’re focused on making a game that’s really good, well, then it is fun. Of course, whether it has any educational value is pretty dubious.
I've played mathy games for many years.  There are hundreds (never mind the hundreds more using nothing more than a deck of cards).  Here are 20 (and please add your own favorites in the comments):
I find these games to be fun first, and mathematical second.  I use some of these in my classroom and a few to complement or inspire content.  For example, there are some great counting questions that can be asked about Set:


How many cards are in the deck? 
How many sets are in the deck?
What's the greatest number of cards you can have without a set?


I've used Mastermind lessons as a tool to develop the concept of proof with middle schoolers.  Backgammon is a great game to practice probability.  


Overall, though, many of these games present challenges in the classroom: they take too long to play or teach the rules, they require too much set up, they can only be played by a limited number of people, students can play without actually trying to implement any thoughtful strategy, and the big one: it is challenging to convince kids (and schools and parents) that playing these games is not just an extra, froofy, free time activity and a break from doing "real" math.  True, becoming better at chess will most likely not help you become better with fractions, but I've begun to think about how these above games could help develop mathematical thinking and habits of mind.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

New Semester, New Job

While technically I still have the same job (and the job I signed up for) and I'm still at the same school, last week marked the beginning of a significant transition from teaching 6th grade to Calculus.  I've taught both before (sometimes back to back), but going from all sixth grade all the time to all seniors (and a few juniors) all the time has been more jarring than going from one to the other in the same day.


I miss my sixth graders a lot.  They were excited and eager and energetic and brave.  We'd built a pretty fabulous learning environment.  Yes, I still had kids who were struggling with the content, with my style, with the transition to a new school, etc, but I knew who those kids were and they were making real, measurable progress.


Now I start all over again (never mind the fact that if there had been a memorizing/remembering names course in high school and if this course had been a required course for graduation, I'd probably still be sitting on the other side of my teacher desk).


Don't get me wrong.  My calc students are friendly, studious, and smart (in both traditional and non-traditional definitions).  


One gave this great "proof without words" of why 1/3+1/9+1/27+...=1/2


  
See it?  Beautiful!